Only keep the 'better' of the two if its less than a couple years old. If your buying tires might as well have a good spare so when you need it, so it won't fail on ya.
Tires are only good for 5-7 years then they dry rot, heat up going down the road and pop!
Having 4 trailers in the backyard, been there, done that!!
Current boat, I went with a load range 'E' radial tire, if I remember correctly its a 10 ply. Think the weight rating is 2830 lbs. (which gives me 11,320 lbs in carrying capacity) boat and trailer weigh in around 9000 lbs. wet.
What I have learned, get the heaviest tire you can get for the wheel/rim you have, you can always adjust tire stiffness by adjusting air pressure up to the max pressure stamped on tire. Usually for trailers I keep air at max, which will keep tire stiff and heat down.
_________________
2000 248 5.7L DP
'92, '94 SXI 750, '08 STX 15F, '12 Ultra LX 300
Videos